Current User: Guest
Search Forums:


 






UserPost

23:09
September 1, 2009


Pianotuna

Hobo

posts 136

Hi all,

I won't get into the six volt vs twelve volt debate. It is to my mind, foolish, because what matters is the number of available amp hours. In an ideal world I'd use an LI battery pack–but that's beyond my (financial) means. My next choice would be 2 volt cells from Surrette. That is also too much "ouch" for my pocket book.

Here is what is may be done to keep lead acid batteries happy.

1. sufficient capacity in amp hours so that the battery is never taken below 50% of capacity. The more amp hours the merrier.

2. sufficient capacity so that when high watt items such as an electric water heater are used that no battery has more than a 25 amp hour draw (or less–the smaller this number the better).

3. a three stage charging system that is temperature compensated. This may easily be accomplished with solar panels where there are 60 watts of panels per 100 amp hours of capacity.

4. routine maintenance such as watering cells and keeping corrosion down.

5. all batteries to be of same capacity and similar age. It is probably best if they are from the same maker, too.

6. if there is space for an "odd" number of batteries then the first parameter may favor 12 volt units.

7. cost per amp hour is "king", assuming that deep discharge batteries are being considered.

If all these conditions are met the batteries may last a long time.

Regards, Pianotuna

15:59
September 3, 2009


Pianotuna

Hobo

posts 136

Hi all,

Someone on another forum pointed out to me a negative of putting batteries in series.

Here is the sad news.

if one battery only putting out 80 amps–and the other is putting out 125 amps–the total output will be limited to 80 amps. The voltage will still be doubled.

This works as an argument for using 12 volt batteries in parallel rather than 6 volt batteries in series.

Regards, Pianotuna

4:08
September 23, 2009


Pianotuna

Hobo

posts 136

Hi all,

I believe that wiring 12 volt batteries together is not well understood by most installers. It is important to "do it right". If there are only two 12 volt batteries involved then method #2 or #3 from this page will work:

http://www.smartgauge.co.uk/batt_con.html

If there are an *odd* number of batteries then only method #3 will work correctly.

If there are an even number of batteries then method #3 or method #4 will work.

If the batteries are six volt it somewhat harder to "get it wrong", as there can only be an even number of batteries, and most folks don't get more than four–which makes method #2 correct–and method #1 wrong. The installer is likely to "get it right" when there are only two choices.

So far I've not seen correct wiring diagrams on any of the battery makers pages–so no wonder the installers are unaware of the problem. Most of the diagrams I've found are method #1 which is blatantly incorrect and will lead to early failure of the first battery in the "chain". Sometimes method #2 is illustrated–which if there are three or more batteries will result in early failure of two of three batteries.

I believe that errors in wiring have helped to create the myth that "six volt batteries are better".

<!– @page { margin: 0.79in } P { margin-bottom: 0.08in } –>

 

Regards, Pianotuna

23:06
November 17, 2009


Pianotuna

Hobo

posts 136

Hi all,

I've been looking at battery pages for quite some time now and thought I'd share what I've found so far. Some it is heavy duty reading, and there are a *lot* of pages.

http://evbatterymonitoring.com/

http://www.batteryuniversity.com/index.htm

http://www.smartgauge.co.uk/technical1.html

http://www.smartgauge.co.uk/technical2.html

http://www.mpoweruk.com/leadacid.htm

http://www.powerstream.com/1922-FLA.htm

The last item is somewhat dated–but a fascinating read all the same–with lots of good information and some super pictures.


Regards, Pianotuna

21:45
November 29, 2009


Pianotuna

Hobo

posts 136

Hi all,

Here is yet another battery information page:

http://www.engineersedge.com/battery/battery_knowledge_menu.shtml

Regards, Pianotuna

10:56
December 17, 2009


nick1979

Guest

I always find these guys very useful for battery information

http://www.thesafetycentre.co.uk/

Very helpful and informative

19:11
December 27, 2009


Pianotuna

Hobo

posts 136

Hi all,

For those who prefer AGM batteries!

http://www.zimmermanmarine.com/docs/AGM%20article.pdf

And a tongue in cheek comparison of batteries and man's best friend!

http://www.mpoweruk.com/papers/lees_wisdom.htm

I happened upon a how long a battery will last java calculator.

http://www.gizmology.net/batteries.htm

Scroll down the page one screen.

It may be useful to those of us who are "high amperage" users!


Regards, Pianotuna

19:41
December 27, 2009


Pianotuna

Hobo

posts 136

Advantages and disadvantages of a six volt format vs a 12 volt format.

Here are some disadvantages:

Higher resistance due to the external series connection VS internal in a 12 volt.

The external connection is mission critical and is exposed to the possibilities of corrosion far more than the internal connection in a 12 volt format.

Lower ability to produce high amp hour draws for long periods of time (100 amps of load for example)

If the six volt batteries are not totally matched as far as amp-hours then the total output is limited by the "weaker" of the two batteries. I.E. one six volt battery at 90 amp-hours and one at 100 amp-hours will result in a 12 volt battery with a capacity of only 90 amp-hours. If they were twelve volt in parallel and the batteries were 45 amp-hours and 50 amp-hours the total would be 95 amp-hours of capacity. Amps in series don't "add" and amps in parallel *do* add.

For the same size "box" 12 volt format seems to have more total number of amp-hours, which is the most important number for us.

If there is room for three batteries the 12 volt format has the possibility of a 50% advantage on the number of amp-hours of storage.

If one six volt fails then you have no 12 volt power at all. (this would be rare, but possible)

There are also some myths:

Six volt batteries do not have a longer life span, nor do they have greater capacity. They do have thicker plates but the rate of chemical reaction has to run twice as fast–so there no advantage over a 12 volt format as far as life span or capacity.

Advantages of six volt format:

Six volt batteries may possibly better at withstanding mechanical vibrations.

It is harder to wire a six volt based system safely but incorrectly. Many, if not most 12 volt systems may be safely wired–but not correctly balanced. When that imbalance happens it is disastrous as far as both capacity and life span. Hence the myth that six volt is better and lasts longer.

All that said, if you treat your six volt batteries well, or your twelve volt batteries, or your 2 volt batteries and charge them up to 100% state of charge as often as is possible, they will serve you well.

Regards, Pianotuna

1:31
January 7, 2010


Pianotuna

Hobo

posts 136

Hi all,

Yet another link to a battery information page. The information here would favor 2 volt cells.

http://www.rpc.com.au/products/batteries/deepcycle_faq.html

Regards, Pianotuna

21:04
January 17, 2010


Pianotuna

Hobo

posts 136

Hi all,

I found a lovely page that speaks about cold weather use of batteries–it focuses on sealed units.

http://www.cdtechno.com/custserv/pdf/7953.pdf


And here is one on Lead-Acid Battery Efficiency Near Top-of-Charge

http://photovoltaics.sandia.gov/docs/PDF/batpapsteve.pdf


Regards, Pianotuna

11:02
January 29, 2010


Pianotuna

Hobo

posts 136

Hi all,

Be sure to check the shipping date on the units–stale batteries are not a good buy at any price. The shipping code usually appears on a sticker on the battery or a stamp burned into the battery case itself.

The code is a string of letters numbers, but all the real information you need is in the first two characters. Usually, the code starts with a letter that corresponds with the month–'A' for January through 'L' for December (some manufacturer's codes omit 'I'; for them, 'M' indicates December). The second character of the code is a numeral that stands for the year. Thus, a code starting 'A2' indicates that the battery was shipped in January 1992;

Regards, Pianotuna

8:05
January 31, 2010


Pianotuna

Hobo

posts 136

Post edited 16:41 – March 9, 2010 by Pianotuna
Post edited 16:42 – March 9, 2010 by Pianotuna


Hi all,

This time the pendulum swings towards the 12 volt format:

"Reliability analyses in the battery industry have shown that statistically, the life of a battery decreases as the number of cells in series increases. This is not a surprising conclusion but rather an expected result of having units with individual failure rates in a series of such units."

http://www.xpowerbattery.com/B…..teries.pdf


The Optima website prefers a 12 volt form factor rather than twin 6 volt batteries in series. There is also one solar site that agrees.


Want to know who really makes your favorite battery? Surf here:


http://www.jgdarden.com/batter…../index.htm

Regards, Pianotuna

Reply to Post


Reply to Topic:
Battery selection

Guest Name (Required):

Guest Email (Required):

NOTE: New Posts are subject to administrator approval before being displayed

Smileys
Confused Cool Cry Embarassed Frown Kiss Laugh Smile Surprised Wink Yell
Post New Reply

Guest URL (required)

Math Required!
What is the sum of:
8 + 7
   




About the Free Campsites forum

Most Users Ever Online:

14


Currently Online:

4 Guests

Forum Stats:

Groups: 2

Forums: 5

Topics: 89

Posts: 366

Membership:

There are 230 Members

There have been 19 Guests

There is 1 Admin

There are 0 Moderators

Top Posters:

Pianotuna – 136

DumOleBob – 35

nchannen – 15

mcbockalds – 10

nwjeeper@comcast.net – 5

jenn – 2

Administrators: hitekhomeless (118 Posts)